Monday, August 30, 2010

Assignment finished!!!










O my gosh, here is my assignment, finally, and ive just cut it down,added in some pictures and put in a bibliography.So here we go........




Assess the significance of ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting, in the royal Tomb of Persephone at Vergina.

In order to answer this question, we must recognise that ‘The Abduction of Persephone ‘ wall painting is one of the most significantly surviving frescoes from the 4th century BC, found in one of the royal Verginian tombs of Philip II, The Tomb of Persephone. To consider its importance we can analyse its important contribution to the Greek myth, Greek art, and death of one of the most influential Greek rulers in history,whilst comparing its similarity to Ovid’s poem.











Vergina, located in Macedonia, northern Greece, houses the tombs of the royal Macedonian dynasty, including King Philip II and Alexander IV. Occupied during the beginning of the Early Bronze Age, Vergina was at its height during the Archaic and Classical periods of the 7th through to the 4th century BC.As the King of Macedonia during this time, Philip II’s death begun the string of tombs that is famously known to be there today. This area, dedicated to the reign of Philip and his descendants, consists of 3 tombs: the Tomb of Philip II, the Tomb of Persephone, which contains ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting and the Tomb of the Prince, all of which are hugely important buildings in the placement of Greek history.

On 8 November 1977, German archaeologist Manolis Andronikos discovered these three tombs buried in a great tumulus. From the early stages of investigating the site, Andronikos maintained the idea that these belonged to the dynasty of Macedonian Kings, confirming historian Nicolas Hammond’s theory of the same idea. Also uncovered in 1977, the Tomb of Persephone held the most important and intact wall painting of this period. Although it contained no valuables inside, on its walls was this marvellous fresco, showing the Abduction/Rape of Persephone by Hades, the god of the underworld. Possibly the work of either Philoxenes or Nikomachos, famous Greek painters of this period, it is the most amazing painting of its time, supported by the shreds of pottery left in the tomb.





Throughout Greek mythology, Persephone has been perceived as the innocent goddess of the four seasons and all that grows and dies within them. This significant status in history is connected to the Greek myth, The Rape of Proserpina, visually presented in ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting. Told by the Roman poet, Ovid, ”the terrified goddess cried out for her mother...(as) her abductor rushed off in his chariot...through the ruptured earth”[1]. In the wall painting, Persephone is seen with a panic-stricken face and with obvious resistance. Hades, with his firm grip on Persephone drags her away on his chariot, determined and led by Hermes. One of Persephone’s attendants, Cyannae is left in despair and clearly frightened. Very similar in scope to Ovid’s poem, we can safely say that this was a well known story throughout the history of Greek mythology. This scene is not only a “representation of the concept of seed and its earth with all its brutal implications”[2], but its symbolic connection to the death of Philip II and his family of kings.

Placed on the north wall of the Tomb of Persphone, the great artistry and technique of this wall painting was almost forgotten amidst the gold and glitter of the discovery of these tombs. Dated to around 340 BC, this painting was composed in the time of Classical and Hellenistic Greek art. Advances in realistic painting technique grew, which led many artists to focus their efforts on panels and frescoes during this time. ’The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting is an example of this, where its free flowing lines, rapid brushstrokes and pastel colours allowed for the naturalistic intention of most Hellenistic painters. As it is a very strong and dramatic work, it creates an illusion of depth and of the three-dimensional. The softness of the painting, gives a very reliable indication of the aims of Hellenistic and Classical painting, as it is one of few that remain closely intact to convey these ideas.









Classical and Hellenistic art spanned the years between 500-27 BC. Where the red-figure in vase painting soon declined, it gave rise to human movement, freedom, expression and nature. Painting also began to take over as well, leaving sculpture in the Archaic and Dark Age’s of Greek art. As only a handful of these frescoes survive, the best preserved is ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ .The contours and structure of the two main figures are shaded realistically, such as the delicate, pink ,and folded fabric on Persephone and the . The composition of these figures and the way they flow together also suggests human likeness, though with the added divinity of most Hellenistic art.

Though robbed of all antiquities during the invasion of the Gauls in the 3rd century BC, the Tomb of Persephone still upholds ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting. Measuring 1m high by 3 m long, this painting was slightly damaged by this robbery, causing small fractures to occur along its face. This is not the only damage this painting has encountered, such as the wear of hundreds of years and the eventual sag of colours from its original palette. Damage of this kind, to such a significant painting, has led to the major reconstruction, repaint and replaster it attained during the 1990’s.Creating a new scene for the viewer, it has dramatically impacted on its brilliance in the 20th century.











Due to the reconstruction of this painting and discovery of The Tomb of Persephone, Vergina has had significant worldwide renown during the late 1900’s.Since November 1997, the tombs and their treasures have been on display, highlighted in showcases and covered in a huge earthen mound. An underground building was also constructed to maintain the temperature and humidity necessary to preserve the amazing wall paintings, in particular, ’The Abduction of Persephone’. To protect this, the lighting has been subdued to focus on it and the particular Tomb of Persephone has been closed off, unable to be accessed by the public. Now a tourist site and converted into a museum, ’The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting has gained international recognition and drawn all eyes on Greece.





With the analysis of its contribution to Greek mythology, Greek art and the death of Philip II, we can conclude that the 'Abduction of Persephone' wall painting, dated to c.340BC and found in the Tomb of Persephone at Vergina, has become a very important contributor to Greek history, past, present and future.

Bibliography:
*http://books.google.com.au/books?id=vt9JwsNckzwC&pg=PA191C1pg=PA191dq=technique+of+rape+of+persephone+painting&

source=bl&ots=irg4cv56KT8

*http://essentialhumanites.net.paint2_2.htm

*http://macedoniaontheweb.com/forum/macedonian-archaelogy-artifacts/744_-artifacts-royal-tombs-elizabeth-carney.html

*http:www.macedonia-heritage.gr/HellenicMacedonia/en/C1.1.6.3.html

*http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vergina

*http://macedonians.multiply.com/photos/album/8/VERGINA

*http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persephone

*http://www.oup.com/ss/companionwebsites/9780195308044/studentresources/chapters

/ch15/representations-in_art/?view=use

*The Ancient Greeks,M.I.Finley,1963

*A history of Greece to 322 BC,Third Edition,N.G.L.Hammond,1959

*Ancient Greece:A Political,Social and Cultual History,S.B.Pomeroy,S.M.Burstein,W.Donlan,J.T.Roberts,1999

*Unlocking the Past-Preliminary Studies in the Ancient World,J.Lawless, K.Cameron,C.Young,Thomson/Nelson,1996,1997 Winner of NSW Premier's History Awards

*http://www.about.com/Persephone_myth
*http://www.poets.org/viewmedia.php/prmMID/19858
Word Count:
1,097

[1] Ovid,Metamorphoses Book V
[2] Letter, Adolph Gottlieb & Mark Ruthko,
Jun 7,1943:On the myth of Persephone






















Thursday, August 26, 2010

another primary source

The Rape of Proserpina
By Ovid, the Roman poet from AD 8

"The terrified goddess cried out for her mother..."
  " 'Cyane, lamenting not just the goddess abducted,
but also the disrespect shown for her rights as a fountain,
tacitly nursed in her heart an inconsolable sorrow;
and she who had once been its presiding spirit,
reduced to tears, dissolved right into its substance."

"Her abductor rushd off in his chariot,urging his horses,calling each one by its name and flicking the somber,rust coloured reins over their backs as they galloped...through the ruptured earth..."
  " 'Meanwhile, the terrified mother was pointlessly seeking
her daughter all over the earth and deep in the ocean.
Neither Aurora, appearing with dew-dampened tresses,
nor Hesperus knew her to quit; igniting two torches
of pine from the fires of Etna, the care-ridden goddess
used them to illumine the wintery shadows of nighttime;
and when the dear day had once more dimmed out the bright stars,
she searched again for her daughter from sunrise to sunset.

-Metamorphoses,Book V
These are from the site:
http://www.poets.org/viewmedia.php/prmMID/19858

Monday, August 23, 2010

Draft essay :)

Yesterday,the 22/08/10,Iwas writing for about 1 and a half hours and finished about 3/4 of my essay.
Today,the 23/08/10,I sat and just wrote for an extra 1 hr and wrote the rest of my essay and now I have it completed.
Here is my draft essay and Sir I was wondering if you could possibly check it out and comment on it,
thanks.
:)
I also forgot to blog this really helpful textbook-
Unlocking the Past-preliminary Studies in the Ancient World,J.Lawless,K.Cameron & C.Young,Thomson/Nelson,1996,Winner of 1997 premier's History Awards:-another book I borrowed form ouur school library on the 16th of August.

ps:does it have to have anymore primary sources in it or not?


*Assess the significance of ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting, in the royal Tomb of Persephone at Vergina.*

‘The Abduction of Persephone ‘ wall painting is one of the most significant surviving frescoes from the 4th century BC.This naturalistic painting, found in one of the royal Verginian tombs of Philip II, The Tomb of Persephone, it has become an important contribution to Greek mythology,Greek art and death of one of the most influential Greek rulers in history.

Vergina, located in Macedonia, northern Greece, houses the tombs of the royal Macedonian dynasty, including King Philip II and Alexander IV. Occupied during the beginning of the Early Bronze Age, Vergina was at its height during the Archaic and Classical periods of the 7th through to the 4th century BC.As the King of Macedonia during this time, Philip II’s death begun the string of tombs that is famously known to be there today. This area, dedicated to the reign of Philip and his descendants, consists of 3 tombs: the Tomb of Philip II, the Tomb of Persephone, which contains ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting and the Tomb of the Prince, all of which are hugely important buildings in the placement of Greek history.

On 8 November 1977, German archaeologist Manolis Andronikos discovered these 3 intact tombs buried deep in the great tumulus at Vergina. From the early stages of investigating the site, Andronikos maintained the idea that these belonged to the dynasty of Macedonian Kings confirming historian Nicolas Hammond’s theory of the same idea. Also uncovered in 1977, the infamous Tomb of Persephone held the most important and safely intact wall painting of this period. Although it contained no valuables inside, on its walls was this marvellous fresco, showing the Abduction/Rape of Perephone, the goddess of the four seasons, by Hades, the god of the underworld. Possibly the work of either famous Greek painters, Philoxenes or Nikomachos, supported by the shreds of pottery left in the tomb, it is the most amazing painting of its time, though who this artist was, it is unlikely we will ever know.

Throughout Greek mythology, Persephone has been perceived as an innocent and chaste goddess, the keeper of the four seasons, and all that grows and dies within them. This significant status in history is visually presented in ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting, where, she was taken into Hades’ underworld and the planet supposedly experienced a never-ending winter due to her mother's grief. In the wall painting, a contrast is made between the Persephone usually alluded to, where she is seen with a panic-stricken face and obvious resistance. Hades, with his firm grip on Persephone drags her away on his chariot, determined and led by Hermes. One of Persephone’s attendants, Cyannae is left in despair and clearly frightened. This scene is not only a “representation of the concept of seed and its earth with all its brutal implications (and) the impact of elemental brutality”[1], but its symbolic connection to the death of Philip II and his family of kings.

Placed on the north wall of the Tomb of Persphone, the great artistry and technique of this wall painting was almost forgotten amidst the gold and glitter of the discovery of these tombs. Dated to around 340 BC, this painting was composed in the time of Classical and Hellenistic Greek art. Advances in realistic painting technique grew which led many artists to focus their efforts on panels and frescoes during this time. ’The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting is an example of this, where its freedom in line, rapid and shortened brushstrokes and subtle pastel colours allow for the emotional and naturalistic intention of most Hellenistic painters. As it is a very strong and dramatic work,it creates an illusion of depth and of the three-dimensional. The softness of the painting, gives a clear indication of the aims of Hellenistic and Classical painting as a whole, as it is one of few that remain closely intact to convey these ideas.

Classical and Hellenistic art spanned the years between 500-27 BC. Where the red-figure in vase painting soon declined, it gave rise to human movement, freedom, expression and nature. Painting also began to take over aswell, leaving sculpture in the Archaic and Dark Age’s of Greek art. As only a handful of these frescoes survive, the best preserved is ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ .The contours and structure of the two main figures are shaded realistically, such as the delicate, pink ,and folded fabric on Persephone. The composition of these figures and the way they flow together also suggests human likeness, though with the added divinity of most Hellenistic art.

Though robbed of all antiquities during the invasion of the Gauls in the 3rd century BC, the Tomb of Persephone still upholds ‘The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting. Measuring 1m high by 3 m long, this painting was slightly damaged by this robbery, causing small fractures to occur along its face. This is not the only damage this painting has encountered, such as the wear of hundreds of years and the eventual sag of colours from its original palette. Damage of this kind, to such a significant painting, has led to the major reconstruction, repaint and replaster it attained during 1992.Creating a new scene for the viewer, it has dramatically impacted on its brilliance in the 20th century.

Due to the reconstruction of this painting and The Tomb of Persephone, Vergina has had significant worldwide renown during the late 1900’s.Since November 1997, the tombs and their treasures have been on display, highlighted in showcases and covered in a huge earthern mound. An underground building was constructed to enclose and protect the royal tombs, maintaining the stable temperature and humidity necessary to preserve the amazing wall paintings, in particular, ’The Abduction of Persephone’. Featured as the most important piece there, it is one of the last remaining Greek frescoes in such good condition. To protect this, the lighting has been subdued to focus on it and the particular Tomb of Persephone has been closed off, unable to be accessed by the public. Now a tourist site and converted into a museum, ’The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting has gained international recognition and drawn all eyes on Greece.

The most significant painting of the 4th century BC to survive, ’The Abduction of Persephone’ wall painting, located in the Tomb of Persephone at Vergina, not only signifies Greek mythology and the expansion of Hellenistic and Classical Greek art, but emphasises the death of the great Philip II. Rich in emotion and realism, this painting has become such an important part of Greece, both in the past and the present.


[1] Letter, Adolph Gottlieb & Mark Ruthko,
Jun 7,1943:On the myth of Persephone

Saturday, August 21, 2010

I just found this really good book on google which had heaps of information on this painting and this was the site:
It was called:Art in the Hellenistic Age by Jerome Jordan Pillott,1986

This is the tomb in Vergina and I think i might put it in my essay somewhere.This picture is sourced from:





I also have used some research from these sites:

And I also finally found out the difference between Hades and Pluto:
Hades is Greek
Pluto is Roman
and they are both names for the god of the underworld.....

This is Manolis Andronikos,the guy who excavated the tombs...
and is from this site:

I have been researching for about 50-55 mins now and I think i'm going at a pretty good speed.Ive got most of my information and i just need to start writing.All this information is starting to flow together now and I have a very clear understanding of my topic after ALL this research.

:)


These are the foundations of the heroon which was a abuilding for the cult of the dead kings and the cist grave from it survived.


Essay Structure-Sir......

Hey Sir,
Could you possibly check out this essay/paragraph structure and tell me if its ok?

1)Intro.
2)History of Vergina tombs
-Philip II
-how many are there?
3)Archaeological discovery
-Andronikos
4)What the painting shows,how it explains myth and what does it mean
-sig.of Persephone
-shows nature and season story
5)Significance in the Vergina tomb
-death of nature
-death of Philip II
-major collapse
-why does it have its own tomb?
6)Technique of the painting and by who
-fresco style
-painter
-colours
-paint application
-composition
-size
-3D look
-naturalistic and realistic;evoked emotion
7)How it fits into art history
-new era of art
-Hellenistic freedom,human movement and nature
-painting rather than sculpture
8)Reconstruction
-robbery
-hole in it
-repainted and replastered
9)Tourist site and preservation
-in a museum site
-kept from public and closed off
10)Conclu.

I have also been researching for about 1 and 1/2 hrs on the technique of the actual painting in the tomb.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

Sources

I borrowed these books form the school library on the 18/8/10:

*The Ancient Greeks,M.I.Finley,1963
*A History of Greece to 322 BC,Third Edition,N.G.L.Hammond,,1959
*Ancient Greece:A Political,Social and Cultural History,S.B.Pomeroy,S.M.Burstein,W.Donlan,J.T.Roberts,1999

These books expressed some ideas behind the growth of Greek art and the way they have been changed over time.
The Verginian art fresco uses these Hellenistic art views in its concept and I thought they were quite helpful,though the few paragraphs in each book were quite short and simplified.

Monday, August 16, 2010

Final Question:

I think i have my question and this is it:

Assess the significance of the 'Abduction of Persephone' wall painting in the royal Tomb of Persephone at Vergina.

A few pointer's on my essay:

These are some of the things I have also found out about this painting and will possibly add it in my essay:

*The tomb of Persephone is part of a 3 tomb find
*It was archaeologically found in 1977/8
*The interior of this tomb is not visible to the public
*This painting has been restored
*This painting and the tomb have great significance in terms of Philip II, Alexander the Great(who I was contemplating doing my essay on earlier,though it was such a broad topic I decided to steer clear of that one),and his son.
*The technique used to get such a good fresco,like all Greek and some Roman frescos,of course borrowed from Greek technique
*There is an unknown reason why Hades/Pluto wants/rapes/abducts Persephone-possible power,jealousy,anger,lust,evil because of evil.....who knows?
*It is a painting situated close to the decline of Greek painting though it is amazingly crafted
*It uses a subtle colour palette
*The tomb had been previously robbed,this is part of the reason why the painting is damaged and needed restoration
*It represents a significant Greek myth and partly tells the story of an aspect of creation
*Persephone,though innocent,young and beautiful has become commonly associated with the underworld
*Was she a willing participant or a poorly judged young woman of high nobility just snatched away?-(Godliness)
*Who are the others in the painting?
*What is its significance in art history from this painting and in this tomb
*What is it doing in this tomb?

Even though it is just a painting,it has a large role to play.

To be or not to be,that is the question...

Would you call it a rape or an abduction?Or even both?
Hmmmmmm.....................

A beginner's story of mythological mayhem and misfortune....

Here is the story/myth of the Rape of Persephone that I would like to share with everyone:

Demeter, the goddess of the crops and harvest, and Zeus, the king of the gods, had a daughter, Persephone. One day while Persephone was gathering wild flowers she was abducted by Hades, the god of the underworld where the dead live.
Distraught when she cold not find her daughter, Demeter wandered over the face of the earth trying to find out what had happened to her. She came to Eleusis disguised as an old woman, and was taken in by the king and queen to be the nurse for their son. Each night, while the palace slept, she placed the baby prince in the fire. One night the queen peeked and saw what the goddess was doing. Not unnaturally she snatched the baby out of the fire, and had hysterics. The goddess revealed who she really was and informed the queen that if she had not interfered, the baby would have been made immortal, all the mortal parts of him having been burned away.
Demeter met Hecate, the goddess of witchcraft, who told her that she had heard Persephone calling out one day, and suggested she ask Helios, the Sun, if he had seen what had happened in his daily course across the sky. Helios told Demeter who had abducted her daughter, and Demeter went off to complain to Zeus, who was not only Persephone's father but Demeter and Hades' brother. Zeus refused to intervene, so Demeter withdrew from her role as goddess. Without her no crops could grow, and the resulting famine threatened the extinction of the human race.
Eventually Zeus said that Hades would have to let Persephone go. When Persephone was reunited with her mother, Demeter asked if she had eaten anything while she was in the underworld. Persephone admitted she had eaten a pomegranate seed. Because of this, she now spends one-third of each year in the underworld as the wife of Hades, and two-thirds of the year with her mother. While Persephone is in the underworld, her mother mourns and refuses to allow crops to grow until she gets her daughter back again.
This myth obviously explains the yearly cycle of growth, harvest, and winter.And it also explains the image I put up earlier of Persephone and her love for her pomegranite.....

This was from:http://ancienthistory.about.com/cs/grecoromanmyth1/a/mythslegends_2.htm

Vergina



Ive realised I havent made much progress on the blog part of this assignment ,so I have been researching for about 3 hours and 24 mins, and I have found out quite a bit about The Rape of Persephone wall painting in a Verginian tomb (left) where Greek art has gone through quite a rough patch and a dramatic change over the years, and I have found this timeline to represent it:



Greek Painting


*Greek Dark Age----ca. 1200-800 BC


-protogeometric


*Archaic----ca. 800-500 BC


-geometric


-orientalising


-black-figure


-flat outlined frescos (eg.Tomb of the Diver,Pitsa Panels)


*Classical and Hellenistic----ca. 500-27 BC


-red-figure>decline
-realistic frescos (eg.Abduction of Persephone)


Etruscan
tomb frescos in the Greek style

I have also finally researched heaps and eventually found out that this fresco was in the Vergina Tomb of Persephone,Tomb no.1!.(Sir,i finally got it):)

Gosh,it even has its own tomb!







This is what it looks like in its own tomb,situated on the left hand side of the image.....
The main people in this wall painting are Hades/Pluto and of course,sweet and innocent Persephone.
These are just a few of the websites I have loked at since I have been researching:
and I have written about 2 A4 pages of research notes.

Monday, August 9, 2010

site

found this site on the vergina wall painting.. and the myth behind it.
http://ancienthistory.about.com/cs/grecoromanmyth1/a/mythslegends_2.htm

Topic.....

After pestering Mr Wright heaps about my new topic,and choosing between heaps more,i finally chose a topic,i think,
The myth of the abduction/rape of Persephone and the wall painting in the tomb of Vergina in Macedonia,northern Greece.

Sunday, August 1, 2010

topic

Was researching some more and realised that Vergina was not an easy topic to come by and thought that the Ancient Greek building of The Parthenon was pretty interesting.It's a beautiful building and i really love the style of it so I think ill do that for my topic.just have to choose my question.
oh,btw,found this awesome site:

http://www.sacred-destinations.com/greece/athens-parthenon

Q

Still not 100% sure on my question.....

ideas

Thought of some ideas that would interest me for this task and thought of some paintings of anything that is associated with ancient art would be the best to do.
Mr wright mentioned Vergina wall paintings and I found this site which was pretty helpful:

http://www.docshare.com/doc/10669/Ancient-Greek-Paintings.

Thursday, July 22, 2010